Monday, September 19, 2005

Medicalnewstoday.com's Standards of Excellence

Filed under: Society

The idea behind Medicalnewstoday.com is quite simple. Reprint original press releases from various think tanks, medical companies, universities, etc, add your own headlines--and there you have your medical news for the day. Good idea? Not always. When you have these press releases reprinted by people that probably don't even have medical or journalistic degrees--Medicalnewstoday.com does not actually identify its "editors"--then you get the following types of headlines: New lung cancer blood test available to public.

Wow! Really? The original press release belongs to Golden, Colorado based CeMines, Inc., and is available as a .pdf file here. And nothing in the press release (original headline: "CeMines™ and Colorado Heart & Body Imaging form Strategic Alliance to use the CellCorrect™ LAb test in a novel imaging program for the detection of Lung Cancer") says that a new lung cancer blood test is available to the public:

Roger Attick, CEO of CeMines, stated: "Physicians today have very limited choices of minimally invasive testing as a tool for use in diagnosis of lung cancer at an earlier stage. The alliance between CeMines and CHBI [Denver-based Colorado Heart & Body Imaging, LLC -ed.] has the potential to create a 'best in class' diagnostic protocol..."

It is doubly unfortunate that medical companies and others allow Medicalnewstoday.com to mutilate their press releases this way.

More about CeMines technology...

email this article to a friend      print this!           comments and peer reviews (3)






replies: 3 comments
Open comments are not moderated, although abusive and vulgar remarks may be deleted. Opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of Medgadget.com. Please consult our disclaimer.

I wish to thank the editors of medGadget for living-up to high standards of reporting and practicing responsible journalsm.

Had I not, by mere chance and luck, stumbled across your article - "MedicalNewsToday.com's Standards of Excellence (Society; 19 September, 2005), the fact that my quote in a recent press release issued by CeMines, Inc. had been mis-represented, would have gone unnoticed.

You have just earned a new customer. I am thankful for medGadget's Standards of Excellence....!

Warmest Regards,

Roger Attick, President and CEO
CeMines, Inc.


Posted by: Roger Attick, President and CEO
on September 21, 2005 07:24 AM GMT

To the Editor of medGadget,

Subsequent to my intital post after reading this article, I contacted the Editor of MedicalNewsToday.com and raised several concerns.

I am following-up to let you know that the Editor of MedicalNewsToday contacted me immediately upon posting my comments. The editor and publication staff were very professional. They immediately retracted the first article and printed a copy of the original CeMines press release.

For your readers, I fell it was important they know that it appears this was simply an over zealous journalist who did not completely understand the magnitude of their words and possible implications.

The issue has been resolved and CeMines is very pleased with the outcome. Again, I thank medGadget for their diligence.


Warmest Regards,

Roger Attick
President and CEO
CeMines, Inc.


Posted by: Roger Attick, President and CEO
on September 26, 2005 04:29 PM GMT

Mr Attick,

Thank you for your kind words. Considering the ease of publishing on the internet these days, it is a common occurence to see people writing beyond their sphere of knowledge and responsibility. We just hope you were not troubled by the representations made, and can continue about your business without hindrance.

Best of luck
Gene Ostrovsky
Medgadget


Posted by: G. Ostrovsky
on September 26, 2005 10:34 PM GMT